author and orange book cover

What Baltimore’s “Black Butterfly“ teaches the rest of us

Why does there remain a plethora of social ills the disproportionally affect Black people in America over 150 years after chattel enslavement has ended? “The answer: black communities have been subjected to unrelenting an ongoing historical trauma.“

That’s from The Black Butterfly: The Harmful Politics of Race and Space in America by Dr. Lawrence T Brown in 2021. He coined the term “black butterfly” to refer to the patterns of racial segregation in Baltimore, which mirrors patterns in other US cities.

Below I share my notes for future reference.

My notes:

  • The first shots of the US Civil War were on Baltimore’s Pratt and Light Streets, between Confederate sympathizers and Union troops
  • “America’s spatial racism”
  • Dismantle spatial racism (a process) to establish spatial equity (the outcome)
  • “To implement a robust racial equity strategy, government officials, philanthropies, corporations, and nonprofits must follow these five steps:
    1. Obtain a deep understanding of historical trauma inflicted on Black neighborhoods.
    2. Identify and stop all forms of ongoing historical trauma affecting Black neighborhoods.
    3. Make decision making participatory and deeply democratic for existing residents in redlined communities.
    4. Ensure a meaningful community ownership and wealth-generating stake in all projects, programs, developments, and interventions using collective economics.
    5. Make corrective and equitable budget allocations and funding choices to repair the damage caused by ongoing historical trauma on redlined neighborhoods.”
  • Michelle Sotero’s Model of historical trauma
  • Category 5 (author term) of hyper segregation as coined by Massey-Tannen — spreading “American apartheid “ as coined by Mindy Fullilove 
  • His coining of the black butterfly 
  • Causa Justa group definition: “We define gentrification as a profit driven racial and class reconfiguration of the urban working class in the communities of color that have suffered from a history of disinvestment and abandonment.”
  • Author calls 2014-2020 as the great rebellion
  • Author cites eight Category 5 hyper segregated cities: Baltimore, Chicago, Detroit, Flint, St. Louis, Cleveland, Birmingham, and Milwaukee
  • Historical trauma framework by Maria Yellow Horse Brave Heart
  • Van Jones “whitelash” from 2016 selection night is defined here as “ the racist American tradition of backlash against black progress, rooted in a zero sum framework”
  • Baltimore’s White L and black butterfly
  • Three “whitelash” periods: after reconstruction, after civil rights nd then after Obama
  • April 2014 Baltimore uprising after Freddie Gray’s death
  • Baltimore freedom movement and Morgan college students defeating
  • Nixon John Ehlorich’s explicitly says war on drugs was an intentional strategy to defang antiwar hippies and black communities
  • Why does there remain a plethora of social ills the disproportionally affect Black people in America over 150 years after chattel enslavement has ended? “The answer: black communities have been subjected to unrelenting an ongoing historical trauma.“
  • In 1913 Morgan State attempted to move locations but white Mount Washington residents fought “a negro institution” moving to their neighborhood
  • On Dec. 25 1910, fighting integration, Baltimore Mayor Mahool told New York Times magazine that “ most of us concerned in it are the best friends the colored people have” but they can’t have negroes
  • Successive fights against “a negro colony”
  • Mitch McConnell: our only job is to make Obama a one term president
  • Trump calls Elijah Cummings’s Baltimore home rat infested
  • The ongoing historical traumas that the author highlights include: hyper segregation, resource removal, forced up routings, hyper policing, economic, destruction, and wealth extraction
  • Noliwe Rooks: segronomics (corporates profit from segregating educational system gut author widens the usage)
  • Brazen lack of government enforcement of the 1968 Fair Housing Act mandate to affirmatively further fair housing
  • The Housing Authority of Baltimore city has concentrated its public housing in black neighborhoods and allowed housing choice vouchers to primarily reside in the black butterfly, thereby reinforcing segregation
  • “The flipside of concentrated poverty is concentrated wealth”
  • Special benefit districts: residents localize special funding to serve their narrow interests
  • Exclusionary zoning codes that restrict the where multi family units can be 
  • Charm city Circulator and bike infrastructure like lanes in Baltimore’s “white L”
  • State of Maryland: Built a north south rapid transit line but not east west through black butterfly
  • Economic development like Project CORE and enterprise zone credits maintain Baltimore apartheid 
  • Sagamore TIF by Kevin Plank like others don’t typically really employ residents — port Covington then also got Trump opportunity zone
  • TIFs and PILOTs are tax diversions and tax evasions

Leave a Reply