Media, particularly that which is meant to attract the indifference of youth, has to be more informed by the end user.
Riding the El in Philadelphia, I see this truancy ad with Bill Cosby pretty often.
Maybe I’m just cynical, but this seems so clearly to be an ad that completely ignores its audience. This ad’s message of getting kids to go to school was made by adults, for adults or by high-achieving kids, for high-achieving kids.
I’m not sure I believe that any kid who is at risk for skipping school would look at this ad and be moved to change his or her ways.
It’s a picture of an aged Bill Cosby and a pack of clean cut students, suggesting going to school ‘made me a winner.’ I don’t believe it’s compelling: nameless kids and an older celebrity. I don’t think there is anyone there who, without context, would inspire other students to follow this suggested path.
What would be compelling, I believe, is making clear the looming risks of not graduating high school.
Continue reading Why this truancy ad sucks and what I think would be better